Skip to content

Dog and Cat Training Comparison: What Breed Rankings Can and Cannot Tell You

PawCompass AU · Last updated: 6 Nov 2026

On this page

Before choosing a dog or cat, consider the everyday skills you can practise consistently. This guide compares practical training priorities across 10 dog and 5 cat breeds, explains the limits of historical obedience rankings and highlights individual differences. It does not predict how many days a particular pet will need to learn. For routines suited to each breed, see its "Training time & skills" section.

What does a dog-breed training ranking actually measure?

Stanley Coren's The Intelligence of Dogs described historical working and obedience rankings based on judges' reports. They relate to performance on particular obedience tasks, not overall intelligence, welfare, ease of living with a dog, or the number of days an individual will need to learn a skill. A crossbreed such as a Cavoodle has no separate position in that historical ranking.

The practical comparison below is not a scientifically validated fastest-to-slowest breed ranking. It highlights questions to ask and skills to practise, while recognising that health, temperament, prior experience, environment and reward-based teaching matter for every dog.

When should puppies start training and safe socialisation?

Basic, reward-based training can begin when a puppy settles into a new home, often around eight weeks old. Start with name response, toileting routines, a comfortable harness or carrier, and short recall practice. Dogs can keep learning throughout life; do not treat a breed label as a deadline for basic skills. For a flexible sequence, see the 8–24-week puppy plan.

The Australian Veterinary Association's socialisation policy describes an early sensitive period for puppies (around 3 to 14 weeks) when safe, positive experiences are especially valuable. Socialisation is not the same as mastering obedience commands; positive experiences should continue after that period. With veterinary guidance, low-risk socialisation can begin before the puppy's full vaccination course is complete. Avoid dog parks and contact with animals of unknown health or vaccination status. See the puppy socialisation guide for a staged approach.

Why can two pets learn the same skill at different speeds?

Learning depends on the individual animal and the training conditions, not just its breed label:

  • Previous experience: an animal that has already learned reward cues or has positive handling experiences may find a new task less unfamiliar.
  • Motivation: choose a safe reward the animal values—food, play, praise or access to an activity—rather than assuming one reward suits an entire breed.
  • Health and emotional state: pain, heat, fear, fatigue and distraction can make training harder; respond by reducing difficulty and seeking veterinary advice where needed.
  • Task and environment: a recall cue in a quiet room is not the same task as recall near traffic or wildlife. Build reliability gradually.

Breeding history can suggest tendencies, but it does not define a fixed timetable or remove the need to observe the individual dog or cat.

Does a dog's size determine its training timetable?

No fixed training window should be assigned by size alone. Adjust the environment and physical demands instead:

Dog sizePractical considerationExample breed pages
SmallKeep equipment comfortable; make exercises and rewards accessible without overhandlingDachshund, French Bulldog, Cavoodle
MediumPractise calm greetings, leash handling and recall in increasingly varied safe settingsStaffy, Border Collie, Poodle
Large and giantTeach loose-leash walking, settling and safe handling before strength or size makes management difficultLabrador, Golden Retriever, German Shepherd, Greyhound

Age, health and the individual animal's response should guide the pace. The useful question is whether the exercise remains safe and enjoyable, not whether a breed's supposed golden window has closed.

What should you prioritise when training these 10 dog breeds?

The ten breeds below are not ranked from easiest to hardest. The table offers a starting point for individualised training; it does not claim that every dog of a breed behaves the same way.

BreedPractical training focus
Border CollieMix basic cues with enrichment; teach recovery and rest as well as active skills
PoodleUse varied, short reward-based sessions and check the individual dog's motivation
German ShepherdPractise calm handling and basic responses across low-distraction settings first
Golden RetrieverReward polite greetings, calm behaviour and a consistent recall routine
LabradorBuild calm greetings and impulse control alongside recall and leash skills
CavoodlePractise positive alone-time routines and recall; a crossbreed cannot inherit a fixed ranking
GreyhoundManage recall safety around moving animals and practise with secure containment
StaffyReward loose-leash walking, calm greetings and reliable attention
DachshundKeep toileting routines consistent and work on recall with motivating rewards
French BulldogUse brief sessions that respect breathing, physical comfort and heat sensitivity

Border Collie Training goals should reflect the individual dog's needs, not a claim that one breed will learn a command in a set number of repetitions.

If choosing a dog, also review the relevant breed page's health considerations, daily exercise needs and household fit.

8 basic commands every dog should learn

Regardless of breed, this is the recommended teaching order:

  1. Name recognition — the starting point for everything else; get a reliable response to their name first.
  2. Recall (come) — a safety command that prevents running off or getting lost.
  3. Sit — the most basic self-control command and the foundation for most others.
  4. Stay — a safety command for doorways and getting in/out of the car.
  5. Down — helps a dog settle and relax on cue.
  6. Drop — a safety command that prevents swallowing something dangerous or resource-guarding conflicts.
  7. Leave it — a safety command that stops them approaching or grabbing something off the ground.
  8. Heel — walking calmly beside you, cutting down on pulling and distraction.

Of these, recall and drop/leave it are the most important safety commands — they directly prevent a dog bolting or swallowing something dangerous. If training time is limited, prioritise these three above everything else.

With positive-reinforcement methods and short, enjoyable practice, many dogs can learn these basics. Learning pace and motivation vary by individual, previous experience, health and training environment—not by a fixed breed timetable.

How can you approach training five popular cat breeds?

There is no evidence-based ranking here for which cat breed learns fastest. Cats of any breed can learn reward-based skills such as carrier entry, target following and recall; the appropriate reward and pace depend on the individual. RSPCA Australia explains reward-based cat training.

  • Maine Coon: try a simple target or carrier-entry exercise; observe whether the individual enjoys food or play rewards.
  • Ragdoll: use short, voluntary sessions, allowing the cat to disengage.
  • Burmese: introduce one cue at a time and reward voluntary participation.
  • British Shorthair: watch body language rather than assuming apparent independence means poor trainability.
  • Domestic Shorthair: assess the individual cat's interests without inferring ability from appearance.

Maine Coon An individual cat's engagement and welfare matter more than breed stereotypes or a promised number of training sessions.

Do dogs and cats need different training methods?

Both dogs and cats learn through clear, consistent, positive reinforcement. The best practical setup depends on the animal, the environment and the skill:

  • Rewards: offer food, toys, play or social attention according to what that individual finds rewarding; do not assume dogs work to please humans while cats act only for food.
  • Session length: keep practice short enough that the animal remains comfortable and willing; no fixed five-, ten- or fifteen-minute rule applies to every pet.
  • Safety goals: practise recall and leash skills for dogs where relevant, and cooperative carrier handling or scratching-post use for cats. Both species can face real welfare or safety problems if fearful or poorly managed.

For either species, avoid forcing interactions or using fear or punishment to obtain compliance.

Should trainability rankings decide which pet to adopt?

No. Choose a pet by matching your home and available care time with the individual animal's needs; a historical obedience score is only a narrow piece of context.

  • First-time owner: ask the rescue, breeder or foster carer about the animal's actual socialisation, behaviour, health and support needs.
  • Busy household: favour a manageable day-to-day care plan, not a promise that a particular breed needs little training.
  • Apartment home: assess noise tolerance, enrichment, exercise and appropriate outdoor management as well as size.
  • Rescue or adult pet: allow decompression and trust-building before adding difficult training tasks.

Use each breed profile's family-fit and health sections as questions to investigate, not as a guarantee about one individual pet.

FAQ

How many weeks old should a puppy be before starting training?›

Short, positive training can begin as soon as a new puppy settles in, often around 8 weeks old. The Australian Veterinary Association recommends safe positive socialisation during early puppyhood, including before the full vaccine course is complete when veterinary precautions are followed. Avoid contact with dogs of unknown health status and ask your vet about local risks. No reliable breed-by-breed deadline for learning basic skills is established here.

Is Coren's dog intelligence ranking reliable?›

Coren's historical obedience-judge survey examined working and obedience performance, not every aspect of learning or suitability as a pet. It cannot predict a particular dog's training time and does not give a valid ranking for crosses such as Cavoodles.

Is there an equivalent ranking for cats?›

There is no equivalent validated cat-breed ranking here. Cats of any breed can learn through positive reinforcement; the individual cat, environment and chosen reward matter more than a published breed order.

Does a hard-to-train breed mean it's wrong for beginners?›

No. A historical breed obedience score is not a beginner suitability test. Consider the individual animal, health, energy needs, socialisation history and your ability to provide regular positive training.

Related guides